In partnership with CBSSports.com
You have no favorite boards.
The most viewed topics.
The most replied to topics.
The most up-voted topics.
The most down-voted topics.
The most up-voted posters.
The most down-voted posters.
The most followed posters.
Serious question: Why do so many UT fans think HC experience is a must for this hire?
I don't get it.
Tennessee has had two guys in the past 50 years have great careers in Knoxville that did NOT have HC experience.
Doug Dickey won 2 SEC titles, and if he wouldn't have been so dumb to leave for his alma mater might have won many more. ZERO HC experience when he was hired.
Phil Fulmer obviously is the other.
Between them, 4 SEC titles and one NC.
-Majors had HC experience: Three SEC titles, but he was inconsistent.
-Kiffin had NFL HC experience. No comment needed
-Dooley had HC experience.
I know some fans think UT doesn't need to go that route. It's an all-time power, an elite program. Etc.
I agree that it's an elite historical program. That's a no-brainer.
But so was Oklahoma when it hired Stoops. So was Georgia when it hired Richt. Florida isn't a historical power but is college football's winningest program in the past 22 years. It hired an assistant.
I guess it takes a strong AD to pull it off. A guy with a proven track record.
Personally, I think a TON of people could win in Knoxville. A TON.
Sometimes, rather than focusing on where a coach is today, I think you have to focus on where he will be tomorrow.
There are great assistants out there right now. In 10 years, some of them will be coaching giants.
Someday, people will ooh back and think, "Dear God, why didn't we hire that guy when we had a chance?"
Anyway, my two cents.
I'm curious what the thinking is on your end. I'm just offering an outsiders POV.
Take it easy guys ...
This post was edited by Keith Niebuhr 19 months ago
On Twitter: @Niebuhr247
I agree with you I think may have pigeon holed himself
I would love to see Greg Roman, I do not care about prior HC experience.
i personally dont think HC experience is critical, and im not opposed to an assistant..but who? I think for an assistant to be considered they would have to have coordinator experience at a big time school, with demonstrated success in their position, and then, perhaps most critically, have demonstrated success in recruiting..
Our AD is arrogant and wants to do everything himself. I have no confidence he will make the right move.
Awesome post Keith and there's no doubt you are right. I wish we would start looking at some NFL coordinators as well, obviously Roman since it appears he has actual interest.
I agree, Keith. Hart is the one who placed that requirement on the search.
"When we step on that football field, everyone flips a switch. And it's on..." - Butch Jones
J.Majors for the record had 3 SEC Champs
Staff writer for govols247 — http://www.twitter.com/RyanCallahan247 — firstname.lastname@example.org
Personally think Chavis, Smart, or Grantham would be great hires for UT. Basically people who have coached in the NFL or at least sent a ton of players to the NFL (Chavis) IMO.
247Sports In partnership with CBS Sports