Online Now 2004

The CheckerBoard

The place for inside information on the Tennessee Vols

On this Board 1068
Record: 4783 (12/9/2012)

Online now 2052
Record: 6475 (12/7/2012)

Reply

Vols offer former Auburn commit

  • http://tennessee.247sports.com/Article/Tennessee-Vols-offer-former-Auburn-commit-Jahmere-Irvin-Sills-106151

    A three-star athlete from Elkton, Md., received an offer from Tennessee on Monday, just hours after he decommitted from Auburn, and he's already interested in the Vols.

    Staff writer for govols247 — http://www.twitter.com/RyanCallahan247 — rcallahan@247sports.com

    Ryan Callahan

  • I like this kid

    signature image

    AtomicCityVol ●

  • hopefully willie can get this kid to come to UT. like his speed.

    JettVol ●

  • AtomicCityVol said...

    I like this kid

    Why do you like this kid? We already have all the 3 stars we need, and if Auburn liked this kid after the last couple of years they have "enjoyed" then I am not sure I like him!

    Mike Hardwick

  • I think the positives are the 20 offers, his speed, and how quickly the staff reached out to him suggesting he is a priority.

    Assuming Camion is out, we have a huge need at WR.

    bavw

  • Mike Hardwick said...

    Why do you like this kid? We already have all the 3 stars we need, and if Auburn liked this kid after the last couple of years they have "enjoyed" then I am not sure I like him!

    Cause he is tough and physical..

    signature image

    AtomicCityVol ●

  • bavw said...

    I think the positives are the 20 offers, his speed, and how quickly the staff reached out to him suggesting he is a priority.

    Assuming Camion is out, we have a huge need at WR.

    I thought he projected as a db

    signature image

    AtomicCityVol ●

  • I don't know much about these prospects. But in Jones presser he said he would go after people with the specific "player make-up". Is this,it? 3 stars, 5'10, 180 lbs? He and jenkins both... Would it not make more sense to get a taller corner to cover 6'4" receivers we're up against.... Jmo...

    VFL

    Was going to hear confirmation on Tee this morning.

    UTshanetrain

  • He's a 3 star db, not a wr, who is ranked 579th im America. What's exciting about that

    crush5

  • Too many people are wrapped up in the # of stars a kid has by his name...if a coach can "coach", then stars are meaningless...

    BigOrangeDad90

  • BigOrangeDad90 said...

    Too many people are wrapped up in the # of stars a kid has by his name...if a coach can "coach", then stars are meaningless...

    I disagree, thats like saying there is no such thing as natural talent. Eric Berry was coached, but he had natural talent. Some kids are more athletically gifted than others. You are saying that if you have someone with no athletic ability who was coached as well as someone with naturally more athleticism than most, the end result would be the same. Your logic is flawed, and I respectfully disagree. Thats why they have a saying "you can't teach that" the number of stars matters. Thats why when you have all star, all american players, its special. Your mannings,berrys,wilsons,grahams,lattimores,greens etc.,

    UTshanetrain

  • BigOrangeDad90 said...

    Too many people are wrapped up in the # of stars a kid has by his name...if a coach can "coach", then stars are meaningless...

    It's like taking 2 stock cars, one being a civic with 114 hp, the other being a skyline with 230 hp. Putting top of the line after market parts on them "suping them up" with the best upgrades available and saying they will be equal. Thats rediculous

    UTshanetrain

  • So what are the chances we are using this kid as a stepping stone to a bigger fish? One of his teammates, Kenny Bigelow, is a 5 star DT committed to SoCal. The new staff is at least getting UT in the mind of some bigger recruits at that school.

    mikeltn

  • UTshanetrain said...

    I disagree, thats like saying there is no such thing as natural talent. Eric Berry was coached, but he had natural talent. Some kids are more athletically gifted than others. You are saying that if you have someone with no athletic ability who was coached as well as someone with naturally more athleticism than most, the end result would be the same. Your logic is flawed, and I respectfully disagree. Thats why they have a saying "you can't teach that" the number of stars matters. Thats why when you have all star, all american players, its special. Your mannings,berrys,wilsons,grahams,lattimores,greens etc.,

    Not all kids get evaluated by the same people. Some may only get one look and may have a bad or just average game while being evaluated. It happens. So the natural talent thing could apply to a 3* also. A coach may look at tape and say "That kid may only be a 3*, but he has a lot of talent." The list of superstar NFL players that were 3* or lower is too long to go into again on this board, but there are many. Yes, 5* players are typically good, but not a sure thing. UT has missed on several 5* players in the last several years. So much more goes into selecting good players for a coaches system than just the number of stars.

    Trample the Weak-Hurdle the Dead

    TracyB467

  • This post is for members of GoVols247 or All Access VIP members only. Start Free Trial
    signature image signature image signature image

    volsfaninohio

  • WVU has been pressing him hard but it appears he is looking for "bigger" offers. It seems that WVU is just a fall back plan. The Mountaineers currently have 2 commitments from his teammates but that doesn't appear to have any influence on JIS decision. If he doesn't come to WVU I hope he ends up in Knoxville.

    signature image

    "Why the f--- did you pass to him? He hasn't made a shot since Moby Dick was a minnow!" Huggs yelling at Butler for passing to Smalligan

    BronxBoss

  • guy's 3 star is better then 2 star? star doesnt matter has long has he is fast we need fast fast fast players..jones can coach these boy's up..win first then 5 star's will come in slow but come..again speed speed we need speed.go vols

    vols4life1969

  • vols4life1969 said...

    guy's 3 star is better then 2 star? star doesnt matter has long has he is fast we need fast fast fast players..jones can coach these boy's up..win first then 5 star's will come in slow but come..again speed speed we need speed.go vols

    JIS has been a 3 star recruit since his JR season and due to issues with his school he didn't have a senior season. Without the ability to play games he obviously didn't have an opportunity to have a senior tape evaluated.

    signature image

    "Why the f--- did you pass to him? He hasn't made a shot since Moby Dick was a minnow!" Huggs yelling at Butler for passing to Smalligan

    BronxBoss

  • UTshanetrain said...

    I disagree, thats like saying there is no such thing as natural talent. Eric Berry was coached, but he had natural talent. Some kids are more athletically gifted than others. You are saying that if you have someone with no athletic ability who was coached as well as someone with naturally more athleticism than most, the end result would be the same. Your logic is flawed, and I respectfully disagree. Thats why they have a saying "you can't teach that" the number of stars matters. Thats why when you have all star, all american players, its special. Your mannings,berrys,wilsons,grahams,lattimores,greens etc.,

    Then please explain Johnny Manziel who was rated 3 stars out of high school. VFL

    slytyger1618

  • There were SEVERAL 3 star starters on Saban's first Bama championship team. And there are MANY 3 and 2 star guys playing in the NFL right now. There are also LOTS of 4 and 5 star guys that NEVER see the light of day in college or pros. Just sayin'............

    Coach85

  • Coach85 said...

    There were SEVERAL 3 star starters on Saban's first Bama championship team. And there are MANY 3 and 2 star guys playing in the NFL right now. There are also LOTS of 4 and 5 star guys that NEVER see the light of day in college or pros. Just sayin'............

    Yep, but why doesn't Saban have a lot of 3-and 4-star players now? Answer: Because it is always better to start with 4- and 5- star recruits, not because of the stars but because (all things being equal) a higher percentage of them are likely to be excellent.

    Not saying coaching doesn't make a huge difference, because it does. But there's a formula for that.

    Average talent + excellent coaching = above average player
    Excellent talent + excellent coaching = excellent player

    RealGlobadoc

  • Elkton, MD! That's where I'm from!

    Need to make a phone call to my sister to see if she knows anyone who can convince him to come. lol

    EDIT: Apparently her boyfriend was 'recruited' to play for ECA at one point.

    This post was edited by petergaultney on 12/11/2012 at 12:51 PM

    petergaultney

Tennessee
247Sports
Features
Resources
Connect

247Sports In partnership with CBS Sports